3 Comments
User's avatar
David Selden's avatar

Daniel - Thank you for the historical perspective and fact-based (to the extent facts exist) report. While I understand the imperative to track down and eliminate these men, I ponder if these pursuits contribute in any way to a longer term strategy.

Yishai White's avatar

If there is any long-term strategy in the last 3 years of war, it is restoring deterrence through overwhelming force against our enemies, and dealing with the fallout from our friends from a position of strength in a more secure future. Seeing as these targeted assassinations have carried remarkably little diplomatic cost and convince a generation of young Arabs that there is no profit to be had from terrorism, I see no reason not to continue.

Jack Eiferman's avatar

Daniel - Thanks for this history and perspective. Looking at this video, it seemed that there were at least two other people in the immediate vicinity of the explosion (I'm guessing within 5 meters): the pedestrian to the right of the target and the driver of the adjacent car (plus any passengers in the car). While deaths of civilians (I'm assuming the non-targets were civilians and were killed) is permissible under the rules of war, I am uncertain if retribution-focused killings is governed by those rules. If those rules apply, then for the killing of these civilians to be justified, they must be outweighed by the military benefit. In this context, is this such a military benefit? I shed no tears for the killings of those who participated in October 7th, but collateral deaths are very different.