11 Comments
User's avatar
CarlW's avatar

Tamar seems to find Americans her age ignorant and incurious. I'm an old American and it saddens me that I think her perception is accurate.

Kathy Schneider's avatar

Thank you! What a lovely wonderful yiung lady! Wishing her מכח אל כח ומחייל אל חייל. חזק ואמץ!

Also, as a Zionist Canadian from Toronto, shocked that ata Zionist summer camp there would be such an ignorant American councellor. Yes Jeqish Americans are ignorant and left leaning but shocking at a Zionist camp!!

Jason Leinwand's avatar

amazing perspective and so worth while to hear her experience in her Israel program and as a US counselor

Rhonda Bogard's avatar

This is such an important conversation- is there any way you could make it public so it could be shared? Her experience is powerful and puts into words much of what so many of us feel.

Bless America's avatar

I can understand her perspective. There are powerful reasons for it, and quite obvious to all. She left out another hopeless sector: the haredim. Arabs are nationalistic and still claim victimhood; American Jews, the leftist ones, have traditionally been less supportive of Israel when push came to shove, beginning with support for the new State of Israel. Jews in general are notorious for being divisive and , specifically in the Diaspora, quick to fear, a sort of eternal Stockholm syndrome, to the point of siding with those who would eliminate them. But then there are Jews in Israel, Israeli Jews, a sizable minority, who abuse the state, coerce others and refuse to defend the state that supports them and agrees to their extortion . They are a disgrace to the entire Jewish people. Are they hopeless? Left to their own devices, yes. Perhaps the day is soon to come when Israelis see the light and force them to integrate the nation. It's Jewishly immoral to allow them to continue.

Lou Spiro's avatar

This is an incredibly important conversation that demonstrates very different world views between Israeli and US teens about what takes place in Israel, especially post Oct 7. This should be required listening for all US Jewish professionals so that they can develop different approaches with Jewish teens (and probably younger ones) to better explain the Israeli narrative in contrast to what Jewish teens see on social media. Otherwise this is likely to become a wider gap as US teens continue to be bombarded with anti-Israel messages

Lou Spiro

Zalman Stein's avatar

Listening to Tamar's thoughts and stories, especially before Rosh HaShanah made me very sad.

Young people her age should hopeful, positive and idealistic. Being cynical, disappointed and negative should be left to old people like myself. When Tamar spoke I could hear the pain in her voice and I felt it too ! Yet within this cocoon of sadness there was a warm and shining moment that is an important lesson for us for Rosh Hashana. When Tamar spoke of being an Israeli, no matter she was and even by herself, she was never alone. She felt the love and community of that

"Israeliness." The tone of her voice changed to being positve and bright. I could feel the bond that she was talking about. Just like there are times when two people see one another and connect even without exhanging words. If I may add we as Jews, not just Israelis, where ever we are may we experince that love and bond.

Alec's avatar

Very strong and courageous young woman. Sadly, most young American Jews (by report, not survey) do not have the strength she has. Sadly, we have somehow lost the ability to converse when you are not "on the same page." This problem also is at the root of the second experience. It's not surprising to me that the young American woman wouldn't engage in a conversation of the type described.

We, here in the US are fortunate in that we are isolated from the rest of the world by two oceans. Sadly, this advantage may have contributed to the difference in openness.

While there may be bridge building organizations (in Israel) created by Arabs, the only ones I have heard of have have been created by Jews. I would suggest that implies a different educational approach that cannot be overcome simply. Einat Wilf has described this phenomenon quite well in her recent book.

Elaine Adelman's avatar

I’m so sorry that this lovely young girl had a relationship with two distinct people whose attitude towards Israel was shocking to her.

We’re talking here about two people, not exactly a number that could give us a good read on what either demographic believes. I can’t help but think that the summer camp that she went to should have done a better job selecting counselors that are supportive of Israel even if the aren’t the super Zionists so many of us are. I know that in the younger generation there are lots of people, who lean left which usually means they are not pro-Zionist. Hopefully as they get older and get more knowledgable things will change.

As far as Israeli Arabs., When I was in Israel just two months before October 7 I met several Arabs who said they wouldn’t want to live outside of Israel, and certainly not in the West Bank. One young man told me about the economic advantages living in Israel provides him. Now granted , I am talking about a statistically small sample but I cannot believe those numbers are not higher and more pro Israel than what one would gather from the young woman’s interaction with the Arab Israeli girl. One has to consider the people that make up the Israeli Arab party, Ra’am.

I hope they continue to design more programs that are better at selecting young people that have a greater likelihood of meshing with counterparts from different backgrounds, at least in terms of their willingness to learn more about Israel.