3 Comments

Social contract argument is hard to follow. Is the contract absolute? If it required certain death of a hundred soldiers to free the hostages would the social compact require it? How about 100 civilians?

Expand full comment

Interesting to compare this interview with Dan Senor’s recent podcast interview with Michah Goodman.

Expand full comment

"...studying the Torah protects the people of Israel." Well, no. I for one do not believe it at all. To be honest, this is a fairly new ultra-Orthodox rant that was created in response to complaints about the shameful ultra-Orthodox draft evasion..."

I hate to say this, but this isn't true. I friend of mine who volunteered in Israel in '73 heard it with her own ears from haredim who were 'defending the State' by sitting in a yeshiva in Tzefat.

Expand full comment